Partial Function Application is not Currying

These two related concepts are often confused. Until yesterday I thought they were the same thing myself.

Often you will see in computer books and articles a pattern where a function is applied to some but not all of it's required arguments, resulting in a function of fewer arguments. In python, this looks like this (from PEP 309):

def papply(fn, *cargs, **ckwargs):
    def call_fn(*fargs, **fkwargs):
        d = ckwargs.copy()
        return fn(*(cargs + fargs), **d)
    return call_fn

This is called "partial function application" - it returns a function which acts like the function you pass in but which takes fewer arguments, the others having been "bound in". The author of this code, however, had the (very common) misconception that this is currying, and called his function "curry" as a result. I shared this misconception for some time, and thought that currying and partial application were the same thing. In fact they are to certain extent opposites.

Where partial application takes a function and from it builds a function which takes fewer arguments, currying builds functions which take multiple arguments by composition of functions which each take a single argument. Thus we curry in python like this:

def addN(n):
    return lambda x: x + n

def plus(a, b):
    return addA(b)

Now why would we ever want to do that? Well, in some pure functional languages this is exactly how functions with multiple arguments are built up. In ocaml, a function which takes two ints and returns a float is actually a function which takes an int and returns a function which takes an int and returns a float. In this world, partial application just happens without any extra code:

% rlwrap ocaml
    Objective Caml version 3.09.3

# let add a b=a+b;;
val add : int -> int -> int = <fun>

So the type of add is a function which takes an int and returns a function which takes an int and returns an int.

# let add2=add 2;; 
val add2 : int -> int = <fun>

add is a curried function, so here we can partially apply by just calling with a single arg- it returns the function that takes the other arg and returns the result.

# add2 34;;
- : int = 36

...and we can call add2 with a single argument as you would expect. Because ocaml curries add for us, the function has been partially applied. It's interesting to note that in ocaml if you label your function arguments, they can be partially applied in any order.

Unless otherwise specified the contents of this page are copyright © 2015 Sean Hunter. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.